| Year |
Player |
Class |
Position |
Honor(s) |
| 1994 |
Ken Higgs
Marc Bunco
Dean Coccia
Chris Cutler |
Senior
Senior
Sophomore
Senior |
Midfielder
Goalie
Attack
Defender |
1st Team
2nd Team
2nd Team
2nd Team |
| 1995 |
Keith Abel
Dean Coccia
Matt Hoppe |
Senior
Junior
Sophomore |
Defender
Attack
Attack |
2nd Team
2nd Team
Honorable Mention |
| 1996 |
Dean Coccia
Steve Hallowell
Matt Hoppe |
Senior
Junior
Junior |
Attack
Defender
Attack |
1st Team
1st Team
2nd Team |
| 1997 |
Steve Hallowell
Matt Hoppe
Mike Sargent
Scott Schenzer
John Torpy
Bo Schrott |
Senior
Senior
Junior
Senior
Senior
Junior |
Defender
Attack
Midfielder
Midfielder
Goalie
Attack |
1st Team/Player of the Year
1st Team
2nd Team
2nd Team
2nd Team
Honorable Mention |
| 1998 |
Mike Sargent
Rob Witte |
Senior
Junior |
Midfielder
Attack |
1st Team
2nd Team |
| 1999 |
Gaelen Cross
Rob Witte |
Junior
Senior |
Defender
Attack |
2nd Team
2nd Team |
| 2000 |
Brett Sweeney
Gaelen Cross
Joey Ellis
Brian Nottingham |
Junior
Senior
Freshman
Sophomore |
Attack
Defender
Midfielder
Goalie |
1st Team
2nd Team
2nd Team
Honorable Mention |
| 2001 |
Joey Ellis
Tom Brown
Dave Riley
Jason Wiles
Brett Sweeney |
Sophomore
Junior
Senior
Senior
Senior |
Midfielder
Attack
Midfielder
Defender
Attack |
1st Team
2nd Team
2nd Team
2nd Team
Honorable Mention |
| 2002 |
Joey Ellis
Josh Hanlon
Tom Brown
Greg Elko |
Junior
Sophomore
Senior
Junior |
Midfielder
Defender
Attack
Defender |
1st Team
1st Team
2nd Team
2nd Team |
| 2003 |
Joey Ellis
Josh Hanlon
Pete Shaffer
Greg Elko
Joe Pappafotis
Rob Weaver |
Senior
Junior
Junior
Senior
Senior
Sophomore |
Midfielder
Defender
Midfielder
Defender
Midfielder
Midfielder |
1st Team
1st Team
1st Team
2nd Team
2nd Team
2nd Team |
| 2004 |
Josh Hanlon
Pete Shaffer
Rob Weaver |
Senior
Senior
Junior |
Defender
Midfielder
Midfielder |
1st Team
2nd Team
2nd Team |
| 2005 |
Steve Hoffman
Curtis Schaeffer
Rob Weaver |
Sophomore
Junior
Senior |
Midfielder
Defender
Midfielder |
1st Team
Honorable Mention
Honorable Mention |
| 2006 |
Curtis Schaeffer
Kolyn Kirby
Steve Hoffman |
Senior
Senior
Junior |
Defender
Attack
Midfielder |
1st Team
2nd Team
Honorable Mention |
| 2007 |
Steve Hoffman |
Senior |
Midfielder |
2nd Team |
| 2008 |
Gibbs Preston |
Sophomore |
Attacker |
Honorable Mention |
| 2009 |
Mike Hatton
Gibbs Preston
Matt Mummert
Jason Stealy
Bill Warner |
Senior
Junior
Sophomore
Senior
Senior |
Midfielder
Attacker
Long-Stick Midfielder
Defender
Midfielder |
1st Team
2nd Team
Honorable Mention
Honorable Mention
Honorable Mention |
| 2010 |
DJ Rickels
Matt Mummert
Gibbs Preston |
Sophomore
Junior
Senior |
Attacker
Long-Stick Midfielder
Attacker |
1st Team
Honorable Mention
Honorable Mention |
| 2011 |
DJ Rickels
Matt Mummert |
Junior
Senior |
Attacker
Long-Stick Midfielder |
2nd Team
Honorable Mention |
| 2012 |
DJ Rickels
Nick Sicuranza
JS Duke |
Senior
Senior
Senior |
Attacker
Defender
Attacker |
1st Team
1st Team
Honorable Mention |
| 2013 |
Jason Lawrence |
Freshman |
Midfielder |
Honorable Mention |
| 2015 |
Jason Lawrence
Zack Bicho
Drew Cortese |
Junior
Sophomore
Senior |
Midfielder
Face-off Specialist
Defender |
2nd Team
Honorable Mention
Honorable Mention |
| 2016 |
Will Kroppe
Robert Breed |
Junior
Junior |
Defender
Defender |
1st Team
Honorable Mention |
| 2017 |
Will Kroppe
Zack Bicho
Robert Breed |
Senior
Senior
Senior |
Defender
Face-off Specialist
Defender |
2nd Team
2nd Team
Honorable Mention |
| 2019 |
Jakob Katzen |
Junior |
Goalkeeper |
Honorable Mention |
| 2025 |
Jason Fritz |
Senior |
Attacker |
Honorable Mention |