| 1926 |
Umbarger, Nichols |
| 1927 |
Beauchamp |
| 1928 |
Beauchamp |
| 1929 |
Dick Willis |
| 1930 |
Noble |
| 1931 |
Mike Hernick |
| 1932 |
U. Richard Martin |
| 1933 |
John Speicher |
| 1934 |
Janna Randle |
| 1935 |
Wayne Strasbaugh |
| 1936 |
H.S. Martin, Worthington Belt |
| 1937 |
H.S. Martin, Worthington Belt |
| 1938 |
John Barkdoll, Charles Wallace |
| 1939 |
Sam Galbreath |
| 1940 |
Tim Lewis, John Tomlinson |
| 1941 |
Frank Tarbutton, Bob Schockley |
| 1942 |
Bud Blair, Francis Cook |
| 1943 |
Did not play WWII |
| 1944 |
Did not play WWII |
| 1945 |
Did not play WWII |
| 1946 |
Ken Volkart |
| 1947 |
Ken Volkart |
| 1948 |
Jack Spicknall |
| 1949 |
Homer Earll, Jim Heckman |
| 1950 |
Jim Culhane |
| 1951 |
|
| 1952 |
Haugenbuch |
| 1953 |
Dick Linton, Nick Gwynn |
| 1954 |
Ray Davis, Denny Harmon |
| 1955 |
Denny Harmon |
| 1956 |
Denny Harmon |
| 1957 |
Bruce Lee, Gene Michaels |
| 1958 |
John Karror, Bruce Lee |
| 1959 |
John Karror, George Varga |
| 1960 |
Jack Baile, George Varga |
| 1961 |
Jack Baile, Wayne Whitmore |
| 1962 |
Joe Wenderrath, Wayne Whitmore |
| 1963 |
Don Schmidt, Joe Wenderrath |
| 1964 |
Neil Hoffman, Don Schmidt |
| 1965 |
William Spangler, Mike Waghelstein |
| 1966 |
Eric Cobrun, Mike Waghelstein |
| 1967 |
Eric Coburn, Ken Nibali |
| 1968 |
Ken Nibali, Bob Tawes |
| 1969 |
Allen McCoy, Bob Tawes |
| 1970 |
Ron Athey, Allen McCoy |
| 1971 |
Ron Athey, D. Hall |
| 1972 |
R. Hall, C. Keil |
| 1973 |
C. Keil, V. Mummert, R. Spink |
| 1974 |
Chris Hannaby, V. Mummert |
| 1975 |
Chris Hannaby, Frank Jansson |
| 1976 |
John Nawrocki, Steve Schonberger |
| 1977 |
Doug Barnes, Ron Rhodes |
| 1978 |
Dough Barnes, John Patrick, Ron Rhodes |
| 1979 |
John Patrick, Jeff Wahlbrink |
| 1980 |
Alex Gerus, Jeff Rosenberg |
| 1981 |
John Garman, Bob Kline |
| 1982 |
Tay Demir, John Schiavone, Greg Shockley |
| 1983 |
John Montanye, John Schiavone |
| 1984 |
Jamie DeGrafft, Bruce Kracke |
| 1985 |
Phil Blatz, Joe Nattans |
| 1986 |
Don Gardiner, Steve Lutche, Joe Nattans |
| 1987 |
Frank Kratovil, John Sack |
| 1988 |
Frank Kratovil, John Sack |
| 1989 |
Brian Kahling, Frank Kratovil, Mike Looney |
| 1990 |
Carlton Cayward, Pat Colbert, Brian Redding |
| 1991 |
Ron Chesney, Keith Purcaro |
| 1992 |
|
| 1993 |
|
| 1994 |
Matt St. Jean |
| 1995 |
|
| 1996 |
Rick Estes |
| 1997 |
Christian Abildso, Costas Hadjipsaltis |
| 1998 |
Dan Strine |
| 1999 |
Ryan Bowles |
| 2000 |
Dan D'Agostino, Vinny Pedalino, Darren Wolf |
| 2001 |
|
| 2002 |
Ryan Tetteris |
| 2003 |
|
| 2004 |
Trevor Brown, Thomas Kane, Leon Mach |
| 2005 |
|
| 2006 |
Jerome DeFrances, Scott Morrow |
| 2007 |
Bill Druckenmiller, Peter Gaitens, Christian Maisel |
| 2008 |
Paul Seegren, Donzell Tate |
| 2009 |
Paul Seegren, Adam Sommers |
| 2010 |
David Cross, Adam Dolbey, Time Wineke |
| 2011 |
Ben Eveler, Max Rutherford |
| 2012 |
Ben Eveler, Max Rutherford |
| 2013 |
Richard Forka, Shane McCraken, Zach Nibbelink |
| 2014 |
Edgar Escobar, Richard Forka, Shane McCracken |
| 2015 |
Andrew Hofmeister, JP O'Connor, Nick Over |
| 2016 |
Raul Escobar, Nick Over, Kerry Shutt |
| 2017 |
Raul Escobar, Nick Over |
