| 1892 |
C. Bowden, H.G. Watson |
| 1893 |
H.G. Watson |
| 1894 |
Rev. Nicholas Oliver Gibson |
| 1896 |
John Mays Little |
| 1897 |
Holmes Davenport Baker |
| 1898 |
Holmes Davenport Baker |
| 1899 |
B.O.L. Wells |
| 1900 |
I.J. Dashiell |
| 1901 |
L.H. Chaffinch |
| 1902 |
W.P. Roberts |
| 1903 |
John M. Henry |
| 1904 |
John M. Henry |
| 1905 |
Walter Muncaster Higgins |
| 1906 |
Harry Covington Adkins |
| 1907 |
John Samuel Turner, Jr. |
| 1908 |
William Albert Gibson |
| 1909 |
Robert Gill |
| 1910 |
Carl "Molly" Twigg |
| 1911 |
Chandler Sprague |
| 1912 |
Edward Fern Weaver |
| 1913 |
Col. Ernest Franklin Dukes |
| 1914 |
Walter Louis Graefe |
| 1916 |
Hirl Albert Kester |
| 1917 |
Torrence Wolford |
| 1918 |
Holly Martin Keller |
| 1919 |
Rev. Otwald Bryan Langrall |
| 1920 |
Rev. Otwald Bryan Langrall |
| 1921 |
Hugh Ward |
| 1922 |
Gus Hafner |
| 1923 |
Edwin Ralph Groton |
| 1924 |
Smith Byham |
| 1925 |
Ezra Williams |
| 1926 |
Frank Sillin |
| 1927 |
Orville W. Neal |
| 1928 |
Orville W. Neal |
| 1929 |
Charles W. Havens
|
| 1930 |
Paul Bates |
| 1931 |
L.W. Pincura |
| 1932 |
Harold W. Kopp |
| 1933 |
Jimmy Dunn, Al Sadusky |
| 1934 |
Bill Shepherd |
| 1935 |
Nick Campofreda |
| 1936 |
L. Lassahn, G. Lathrop |
| 1937 |
Anthony Ortenzi |
| 1938 |
Edwards Peters |
| 1939 |
Bob Stropp |
| 1940 |
Mark McPike |
| 1941 |
Irvin Biasi |
| 1942 |
Mike Phillips |
| 1946 |
Art O'Keeffe, "Sig" Jensen |
| 1947 |
Stan Kulakowski, Carlo Ortenzi |
| 1948 |
Jim Cotter, Walter Piavis, Simon Tullui |
| 1949 |
Henry A. Corrado |
| 1950 |
Ed Rydzewski |
| 1951 |
Walt Hart |
| 1952 |
Harlow Henderson, Bruce Rudisill |
| 1953 |
Arnie Needleman |
| 1954 |
Ron Jones, Charlie White |
| 1955 |
Howard Hunt |
| 1956 |
Bob Butler |
| 1957 |
Dick Holbruner, Bill Spaar |
| 1958 |
Donald Dewey |
| 1959 |
Joe Bender, Fred Burgee |
| 1960 |
Fred Dilkes, Carroll T. Giese Jr. |
| 1961 |
William R. Bergquist, James F. Pusey Jr. |
| 1962 |
Roy M. Terry III, Richard N. Yobst |
| 1963 |
Thomas E. Bowman, Kenneth T. Confer Jr. |
| 1964 |
Ben Laurence, Art Renkwitz |
| 1965 |
Allan Ingalls, Gary Kulick, Richard J. White |
| 1966 |
Michael Beach, Jay Sybert |
| 1967 |
John Heritage, Don Stout |
| 1968 |
Earl Dietrich, Bill Fanning |
| 1969 |
Bruce Bozman, Reese Diggs |
| 1970 |
Michael Hunt, Thomas Mavity |
| 1971 |
Ken Bowmen, Lawrence Garro, Fred Kiemle |
| 1972 |
Thomas Botts, Nelson Shaffer |
| 1973 |
Roy Angleberger, Mike Bricker |
| 1974 |
Fred DiBlasio, Richard Heritage |
| 1975 |
Richard Heritage, Bob Kehler |
| 1976 |
Dave Dolch, Steve Spinello |
| 1977 |
Donald Enterline, Buck Horsey |
| 1978 |
Gerard Fischer, Michael Sanders, Donovan Truesdell |
| 1979 |
Ricci Bonaccorsy, Eric DeGross, Randy Halsey |
| 1980 |
Bruce England, Steve James, Joe Menedez, Harry Peoples |
| 1981 |
Steve James, Jim Selfridge, Bob Upshaw, Dennis Yancheski |
| 1982 |
Jim Buckley, Kent Galvin, Wayne Keen, Paul Wallin |
| 1984 |
Tony Callahan, Mike Fuller, Wayne Pollock, Mike Toner |
| 1985 |
Tony Callahan, Mike Chavez, Andy Stefanelli |
| 1986 |
Andy Stefanelli, Pete Wilson |
| 1987 |
Rodney Joyner, John Van Lunen |
| 1988 |
Matt Donner, Matt Palazzo, Chris Scannell |
| 1989 |
Pat Crain, Pat Duncan, Mike Hamm, Daryl Reisinger |
| 1990 |
Mike Hamm, Danny Moore, Daryl Reisinger |
| 1991 |
Eric Frees, Andy Steckel, Jim Webster |
| 1992 |
Seth Obetz, Paul Picchierri |
| 1993 |
Keith Abel, Trevor Sellers |
| 1994 |
Matt Lecorchick, Alan Pietkiewicz |
| 1995 |
Bob Symanski, Brian Van Deusen |
| 1996 |
Matt Humphrey, Brian Perrier, Carl Von Tobel |
| 1997 |
Donte Abron, Tom Lapato, Bill Parks, Jay Tharpe |
| 1998 |
Ryan Hines, Tom Lapato, Jay Tharpe, Tom Selecky, Ron Sermarini |
| 1999 |
Aaron Bartolain, Matt Meiklejohn, Tom Selecky, Ton Sermarini, Terry Otto |
| 2000 |
Aaron Bartolain, Jamie "Boo" Harris, Rob McCraken, Scott Shelton |
| 2001 |
Boo Harris, Greg Oravets, Teron Powell, Scott Shelton, Matt Wilchinsky, Jason Wingeart |
| 2002 |
Joey Ellis, Jesse Hudson, Matt Wilchinski, French Pope |
| 2003 |
Troy Mason, French Pope, Joe Szymanek, Todd Williams, Rob Wingfield |
| 2004 |
Jason Hartman, Andy Lee, Brad Stewart |
| 2005 |
Andy Lee, Chris Maruyama, Jay Scott |
| 2006 |
Drew Abbamonte, Brad Baer |
| 2007 |
Brad Baer, Ryan Mellinger |
| 2008 |
Cory Briggs, Matt Cahill, Aaron Slaughter, Eric Zwilsky |
| 2009 |
Matt Cahill, Austin Kerr, Aaron Slaughter, Mike Weick, Eric Zwilsky |
| 2010 |
Matt Cahill, Chris Kolb, Aaron Slaughter |
| 2011 |
Sam Cox, Tam Masucci, Diego Weiner, Kevin White |
| 2012 |
Tyler Lloyd, Tim McLister, Kevin White |
| 2013 |
Mike Cousar, Derrick Miles, Mike Oliveto, Joe Rollins, Pat Tighe |
| 2014 |
Brandon Jones, Mike Oliveto |
| 2015 |
Riley Johnson, Brandon Jones, Mike Oliveto, Matt Quattrone |
| 2016 |
Tyler DeMent, Vince Gorgone, Matt Quattrone |
| 2017 |
Bamasa Bailor, Vince Gorgone, Drew Scott |
